The Beatles vs. Elvis: Which One Would You Pick?

A Vintage Nerd, Vintage Blog, Elvis vs The Beatles, Vinyl Records, Retro Fashion Blog

I remember being told more than a few times if you are a Beatles fan you can't possibly be a fan of Elvis. I never understood the comparison because in my home my mother was a huge Elvis fan and my father is a devoted Beatles fan. I grew up listening to the records of both and loved both equally for their songs.

I don't know where this saying came from but I have heard it numerous times as the years went by. After someone would ask me which I would pick I would just shake my head and always say, "both". How can I choose? But if you were to choose, which would it be? Let's compare the two.

The Beatles:

  • Four young guys from Liverpool, England
  • Melodies for days
  • Catchy lyrics and toe tapping tunes
  • Outstanding bowl haircuts
  • British accents
  • Snappy suits (circa early 60's)
  • A drummer
  • Not afraid to experiment with music
  • A yellow submarine
  • An entire cartoon film dedicated to a yellow submarine


  • One guy from Mississippi
  • Jet black slicked hair
  • Those swingin' hips
  • Soulful voice
  • An electric smile
  • Rock n' Roll
  • Always giving to others
  • Mama's boy
  • Fried peanut butter and banana sandwiches
  • Charming performances as an actor

Its safe to say I stand by my upbringing. I can't choose between the two. Have you? Is there one you love more than the other? Have you heard this saying about not being able to be true fans of both?

Share this:


  1. I reckon it's possible to like both. Over here in the UK it's said you can be Beatles or Stones, but not both. I like both of those too, though my mum and mother-in-law, both young people in the 60s, were squarely in opposing camps. Perhaps it's one of those "had to be there at the time" things.

    1. Ahhh my dad is a Beatles and Stones fan but I never really got into the Stones. Go figure. LOL xox

  2. I've never gravitated towards either. Eek!

    1. Gahhh hahah thats okay there's a lot more out there aside from them! xox

  3. Elvis. Easy. I'm actually not really a Beatles fan.


    1. He's still a dreamboat!! Thanks Janey! xox

  4. Totally OK to be fans of both (I am ;)

  5. E-L-V-I-S, without him there would have never been a Beatles.


Copyright © A Vintage Nerd || Exploring Old Hollywood Through Fashion, Film, & Books. Designed by OddThemes